findalternative.to

7 Best Alternatives to 1Password for iOS in 2026

By Noahlast updated pricing verified

Of the 7 1Password alternatives we track, 7 are available on iOS: Bitwarden, Dashlane, LastPass and 4 more. Each entry below keeps its full comparison from the main list.

All 7 1Password alternatives

Compared: 1Password alternatives that run on iOS

1Password alternatives compared: best for, standout feature, biggest weakness, learning curve, and price
AlternativeBest forStandoutBiggest weaknessLearning curvePrice
1Passwordreferenceindividuals, families, and engineering teams who want a password manager with built-in developer secrets tooling (CLI, SSH agent, CI/CD integration), not just browser autofillWatchtower's continuous audit of every vault for weak, reused, and breached passwords, paired with a CLI and SSH agent that inject secrets into developer workflows and CI/CD pipelines.No permanently free tier: every plan is a 14-day trial that converts to a paid subscription, and Individual/Family customers get email and community support only, with no phone or live chat.LowFrom $3.99/mo
Bitwardenindividuals and teams who want an open-source, independently audited password manager they can self-host, at roughly half the price of 1Password or DashlaneFully open-source client and server code (GPL-3.0), independently audited, with an official self-hosting option and a community-maintained lightweight server (Vaultwarden) for running your own vault infrastructure.The official self-hosted server carries a mixed license (GPL-3.0 core plus a Bitwarden-specific license for some enterprise features), and the interface is generally considered less polished than 1Password's, with fewer built-in extras like a bundled VPN.LowFree tier · paid from $1.65/mo
Dashlaneindividuals and families who want a password manager with a built-in VPN and dark web monitoring bundled into one subscription rather than purchased separatelyAI-powered Scam Protection combined with a bundled VPN in the Individual Premium plan, so Wi-Fi protection and phishing-link detection ship alongside password storage instead of requiring separate subscriptions.Dashlane discontinued its free plan in September 2025, so there is no way to use it long-term without paying, and Business pricing is hidden behind a sales quote rather than published on the pricing page.LowFrom $4.99/mo
LastPassindividuals and small businesses that want a widely compatible password manager with mature browser and OS support, and who are not deterred by LastPass's 2022 breach historyBroad platform coverage across every major browser, Windows, macOS, Linux, iOS, and Android, with a mature enterprise feature set (SSO, SaaS Monitoring) at the Business Max tier.LastPass disclosed two connected 2022 security incidents in which attackers accessed encrypted customer vault backups, and Trustpilot reviewers report ongoing billing, cancellation, and support-access problems; the free tier also restricts sync to a single device type (computers or mobile, not both).LowFree tier · paid from $3/mo
NordPassindividuals who want a genuinely free single-device password manager, or families and businesses already using other Nord Security products (NordVPN, NordLocker) who want a bundled ecosystemA usable permanent Free plan (not just a trial) alongside deep discounts of up to roughly 40% for 2-year Business commitments, plus Enterprise SSO integrations with Entra ID, Okta, Sentinel, and Splunk.NordPass hides its actual paid-plan dollar prices behind a dynamically loaded, promotion-dependent checkout flow rather than publishing fixed numbers, making it hard to compare cost against competitors like Bitwarden or 1Password without starting a purchase flow; the Free plan is also limited to a single device.LowFree
Proton Passindividuals and small teams who want a zero-knowledge, open-source password manager with unlimited free logins and built-in email alias maskingUnlimited hide-my-email aliases (10 free, unlimited on Pass Plus) let a user mask their real email address per signup without a separate aliasing service.The free plan caps hide-my-email aliases at 10 and lacks the built-in 2FA authenticator and dark web monitoring bundled into Pass Plus; like the rest of Proton's product line, getting the best per-dollar value requires bundling into the pricier Proton Unlimited plan rather than buying Pass alone.LowFree tier · paid from $1.99/mo
RoboFormindividuals and families who want a genuinely unlimited free single-device password manager, with cheap multi-device and family plans compared to 1Password or DashlaneA permanently free plan with unlimited stored passwords on one device (not just a time-limited trial), plus breach monitoring across up to five email addresses on paid plans.The Free plan is capped to a single device, so most people who want sync will need a paid plan; RoboForm's G2/Capterra reviews also cite occasional unexpected logouts and repeated re-authentication prompts as a recurring complaint.LowFree tier · paid from $2.49/mo
Keeperbusinesses, MSPs, and government agencies that need password management combined with privileged access management and compliance certifications like FedRAMP High and HIPAAPrivileged Access Management (PAM) with just-in-time access, session recording, and KeeperAI anomaly detection that can automatically terminate high-risk privileged sessions, bundled alongside standard password management.Pricing is not transparent on the public site — dollar amounts are hidden behind a JavaScript-rendered pricing page rather than shown as static numbers — and there is no permanently free consumer tier, only free trials on business plans.LowCustom pricing

1.Bitwarden — best 1Password alternative for individuals and teams who want an open-source, independently audited password manager they can self-host, at roughly half the price of 1Password or Dashlane

Screenshot of Bitwarden

Bitwarden is the best 1Password alternative for individuals and teams who want a password manager they can audit and self-host, rather than trusting 1Password's closed-source vaults. Bitwarden's client and server code is published on GitHub under GPL-3.0 and independently audited, and organizations can run their own server or the community-maintained Vaultwarden project instead of relying on Bitwarden's cloud. Bitwarden's Free plan covers unlimited passwords and devices at no cost, something 1Password doesn't offer since every 1Password plan is a 14-day trial that converts to paid billing. Bitwarden's Premium tier costs $1.65/month billed annually, roughly 40 percent of 1Password's $3.99/month Individual plan, and its Teams tier at $4/user/month undercuts 1Password's Business plan at $8.99/user/month by more than half. Bitwarden holds a 4.7/5 rating from 216 Capterra reviews and 4.8/5 from 16 Product Hunt reviews, both smaller samples than 1Password's 2,130 Capterra reviews. 1Password is still the better choice for teams that want built-in developer secrets tooling: Bitwarden has no equivalent to 1Password's CLI and SSH agent for injecting credentials into CI/CD pipelines, and Bitwarden's interface and browser extension are generally considered less polished than 1Password's.

Compared to 1Password: genuinely free unlimited-device tier vs trial-only pricing, open-source GPL-3.0 code vs closed-source, Premium at $1.65/month vs 1Password's $3.99/month

Wins:Genuinely free tier covers unlimited passwords and devices, vs 1Password's 14-day-trial-only model with no free plan · Open-source, independently audited client and server code (GPL-3.0) published on GitHub, unlike 1Password's closed-source model · Premium tier costs $1.65/month vs 1Password's $3.99/month Individual plan, and Teams at $4/user/month undercuts 1Password Business at $8.99/user/month

Loses:No CLI or SSH agent equivalent to 1Password's for injecting secrets into CI/CD pipelines · Interface and browser extension are generally considered less polished than 1Password's · Rating comes from 216 Capterra and 16 Product Hunt reviews, a smaller sample than 1Password's 2,130 Capterra reviews

Pros

  • Open-source, independently audited client and server code that anyone can inspect on GitHub.
  • Free tier includes unlimited passwords and devices with no artificial time limit.
  • Roughly half the price of 1Password or Dashlane at every comparable tier.
  • Official self-hosting option, plus a community Vaultwarden server for lighter-weight self-hosting.

Cons

  • Free tier excludes the integrated authenticator and file attachments, which require upgrading to Premium.
  • Server code isn't purely open source; some enterprise components ship under a separate Bitwarden license alongside the GPL-3.0 core.
  • Interface and browser extension are generally considered less polished than 1Password's.
  • No bundled VPN or dark-web monitoring the way some competitors include at similar price points.

Pricing: Free tier · paid from $1.65/mo$1.65/month Premium vs 1Password's $3.99/month Individual; Bitwarden Teams at $4/user/month vs 1Password Business at $8.99/user/month (verified undefined NaN, NaN)

2.Dashlane — best 1Password alternative for individuals and families who want a password manager with a built-in VPN and dark web monitoring bundled into one subscription rather than purchased separately

Screenshot of Dashlane

Dashlane is the best 1Password alternative for individuals who want a VPN and continuous dark web monitoring bundled into one password manager subscription, rather than buying separate tools alongside 1Password. Dashlane's Individual Premium plan costs $4.99/month billed annually and includes unlimited password storage, a VPN for Wi-Fi protection, dark web monitoring, and AI-powered Scam Protection that flags phishing links before a user enters credentials — a combination 1Password doesn't offer at any price, since Watchtower audits stored passwords but doesn't include a VPN. Dashlane's Friends & Family plan covers up to 10 people from $7.49/month, close to 1Password's Teams Starter Pack at $24.95/month flat for up to 10 members. Dashlane holds a 4.5/5 rating from 276 Capterra reviews, a smaller sample than 1Password's 2,130. 1Password is still the better choice for buyers who want transparent, published business pricing and native Linux support: Dashlane's Business tier pricing (Omnix Password Management and Credential Protection) is hidden behind a sales quote rather than published the way 1Password lists its $8.99/user/month Business rate, and Dashlane has no native Linux desktop app, unlike 1Password which runs natively on Linux.

Compared to 1Password: VPN and dark web monitoring bundled into Premium at $4.99/month, AI-powered Scam Protection flags phishing before credential entry, Business pricing hidden behind a sales quote

Wins:Individual Premium plan bundles a VPN, dark web monitoring, and AI-powered Scam Protection for $4.99/month, a combination 1Password doesn't offer at any price · Friends & Family covers up to 10 people from $7.49/month · AI-powered Scam Protection flags phishing links before credentials are entered, a feature 1Password's Watchtower doesn't include

Loses:Business pricing (Omnix Password Management and Credential Protection) is hidden behind a sales quote, while 1Password publishes a flat $8.99/user/month Business rate · No native Linux desktop app, unlike 1Password which supports Linux natively · Rating comes from 276 Capterra reviews, a much smaller sample than 1Password's 2,130 Capterra reviews

Pros

  • Bundled VPN included in Individual Premium at no extra cost.
  • Continuous dark web monitoring alerts users when a linked email appears in a breach.
  • AI-powered Scam Protection flags phishing links before credentials are entered.
  • Friends & Family plan covers up to 10 people from $7.49/month.

Cons

  • No permanently free tier since September 2025; every plan starts as a 14-day trial before billing.
  • Business pricing (Omnix Password Management and Credential Protection) is not published and requires contacting sales.
  • No native Linux desktop app, unlike 1Password or Bitwarden.
  • Friends & Family members other than the plan manager lose access to the bundled VPN.

Pricing: From $4.99/mo$4.99/month Premium (VPN + dark web monitoring included) vs 1Password's $3.99/month Individual (no VPN)

3.LastPass — best 1Password alternative for individuals and small businesses that want a widely compatible password manager with mature browser and OS support, and who are not deterred by LastPass's 2022 breach history

Screenshot of LastPass

LastPass is the best 1Password alternative for individuals and small businesses that want a password manager with the widest platform and browser support, syncing across every major browser plus Windows, macOS, Linux, iOS, and Android, matching 1Password's own six-platform coverage but at a lower entry price. LastPass's Premium tier runs around $3/month billed annually with an active roughly-30-percent promotional discount, undercutting 1Password's $3.99/month Individual plan, and its Free tier — though limited to syncing on one device type, computers or mobile, not both — costs nothing, unlike 1Password's 14-day-trial-only model. LastPass holds a 4.6/5 rating from 2,786 Capterra reviews, more than the 2,130 Capterra reviews on 1Password's own listing. 1Password is still the clearly better choice for buyers concerned about vendor security history: LastPass disclosed two connected security incidents in 2022 in which attackers accessed encrypted customer vault backups, and its Trustpilot reviewers cite ongoing billing, cancellation, and support-access complaints that 1Password's reviewers don't raise at the same scale, a real trust cost against LastPass's lower price and larger review count.

Compared to 1Password: matches six-platform coverage at ~$3/month vs $3.99/month, more Capterra reviews (2,786 vs 2,130), but disclosed two connected 2022 security breaches

Wins:Matches 1Password's six-platform coverage (every major browser plus Windows, macOS, Linux, iOS, Android) at a lower entry price · Premium runs around $3/month billed annually (active ~30% promotional discount) vs 1Password's $3.99/month Individual plan · 4.6/5 rating from 2,786 Capterra reviews, more than 1Password's own 2,130 Capterra reviews

Loses:Disclosed two connected security breaches in 2022 that exposed encrypted customer vault backups, a trust issue 1Password's listing doesn't carry · Free tier restricts syncing to one device type (computers or mobile), not both at once · Trustpilot reviewers report recurring billing, cancellation, and support-access complaints

Pros

  • Broad platform support across every major browser, Windows, macOS, Linux, iOS, and Android.
  • Dark web monitoring alerts when a stored email or password appears in a known breach.
  • Business Max tier adds SaaS Monitoring and SaaS Protect for tracking unsanctioned app usage org-wide.
  • Family plan covers up to 6 individual Premium accounts under a single admin-managed bill.

Cons

  • Disclosed two connected security breaches in 2022 that exposed encrypted customer vault data, a lasting trust issue competitors still use in switching campaigns.
  • Free tier restricts syncing to a single device type (computers or mobile), not both at once.
  • Trustpilot reviewers report recurring billing, cancellation, and support-access complaints, a sharp contrast to its higher Capterra rating.
  • Renewal pricing has a documented history of jumping above the promotional first-year rate.

Pricing: Free tier · paid from $3/mo~$3/month Premium (promotional rate) vs 1Password's $3.99/month Individual

4.NordPass — best 1Password alternative for individuals who want a genuinely free single-device password manager, or families and businesses already using other Nord Security products (NordVPN, NordLocker) who want a bundled ecosystem

Screenshot of NordPass

NordPass is the best 1Password alternative for individuals who already use NordVPN or NordLocker and want a genuinely free, permanent single-device password manager rather than 1Password's 14-day-trial-only model. NordPass's Free plan covers one device with password generation, secure storage, and biometric or MFA login at no cost, something 1Password doesn't offer at all since every 1Password tier converts to paid billing after two weeks. NordPass Business plans offer discounts of up to roughly 40 percent for 2-year commitments, and its Enterprise tier integrates with Entra ID, Okta, Microsoft Sentinel, and Splunk for organizations with existing SSO and SIEM stacks. 1Password is still the better choice for most buyers: NordPass's rating here rests on just 1 Product Hunt review, far thinner evidence than 1Password's 1,605 G2 and 2,130 Capterra reviews, and NordPass hides its actual paid-plan dollar prices behind a dynamically loaded, promotion-dependent checkout flow rather than publishing fixed numbers the way 1Password does on its own pricing page, making direct cost comparison difficult. NordPass's Free plan is also capped to a single device, and its Business plans require a minimum of 5 seats.

Compared to 1Password: permanent free single-device plan vs no free tier at all, up to 40% off 2-year Business terms, but paid pricing not published as fixed numbers

Wins:Free plan is permanent and covers one device with password generation and secure storage, vs 1Password's zero free plans and 14-day-trial-only model · Business commitments get discounts of up to roughly 40% for 2-year terms · Enterprise tier integrates with Entra ID, Okta, Microsoft Sentinel, and Splunk

Loses:Rating rests on just 1 Product Hunt review, far thinner evidence than 1Password's 1,605 G2 and 2,130 Capterra reviews · Paid-plan dollar prices are not published as fixed numbers; they render dynamically by billing term and promotion at checkout · Free plan is capped to a single device, and Business plans require a minimum of 5 seats

Pros

  • A genuinely usable, permanent Free plan, not just a time-limited trial like some competitors.
  • Native apps and browser extensions across Windows, macOS, Linux, iOS, and Android.
  • Password Health and Data Breach Scanner flag weak, reused, or compromised credentials on paid plans.
  • Enterprise tier integrates with Entra ID, Okta, Microsoft Sentinel, and Splunk for organizations with existing SSO/SIEM stacks.

Cons

  • Exact dollar prices for Premium, Family, and Business plans are not published as fixed numbers; they render dynamically by billing term and promotion at checkout.
  • Free plan is capped at a single device, with no multi-device sync unless upgrading.
  • Business and Enterprise plans require a minimum of 5 seats, which can be awkward for very small teams.
  • As part of the Nord Security family (NordVPN, NordLocker), some buyers are wary of consolidating multiple security tools with one vendor.

Pricing: Free

5.Proton Pass — best 1Password alternative for individuals and small teams who want a zero-knowledge, open-source password manager with unlimited free logins and built-in email alias masking

Screenshot of Proton Pass

Proton Pass is the best 1Password alternative for individuals who want a zero-knowledge, open-source password manager with built-in email alias masking, rather than 1Password's closed-source vaults with no aliasing feature at all. Proton Pass's Free plan includes unlimited logins, notes, and credit cards plus 10 hide-my-email aliases at no cost, while 1Password offers no permanently free tier whatsoever. Pass Plus starts at $1.99/month billed annually, less than half 1Password's $3.99/month Individual plan, and removes the alias cap entirely while adding a built-in 2FA authenticator and dark web monitoring. Proton Pass's client apps are open source under GPL-3.0 on GitHub, unlike 1Password's closed-source model. 1Password is still the better choice for buyers who want a large body of independent reviews and deep developer secrets tooling: Proton Pass's 4.9/5 rating comes from just 7 Capterra reviews, far thinner evidence than 1Password's 2,130 Capterra and 1,605 G2 reviews, and Proton Pass has no equivalent to 1Password's CLI and SSH agent for CI/CD credential injection. Getting Proton Pass's best per-dollar value also requires bundling into the pricier $12.99/month Proton Unlimited plan rather than buying Pass alone.

Compared to 1Password: free tier with 10 email aliases vs no free tier at all, Pass Plus at $1.99/month vs $3.99/month, open-source GPL-3.0 clients vs closed-source

Wins:Free plan includes unlimited logins, notes, and credit cards plus 10 hide-my-email aliases at no cost, vs 1Password's zero free tiers · Pass Plus starts at $1.99/month, less than half 1Password's $3.99/month Individual plan · Client apps are open source under GPL-3.0 on GitHub, unlike 1Password's closed-source model

Loses:4.9/5 rating comes from just 7 Capterra reviews, far thinner evidence than 1Password's 2,130 Capterra and 1,605 G2 reviews · No CLI or SSH agent equivalent to 1Password's for CI/CD credential injection · Best per-dollar value requires bundling into the pricier $12.99/month Proton Unlimited plan rather than buying Pass alone

Pros

  • Free plan includes unlimited logins, notes, and credit cards, not just a capped vault size.
  • Hide-my-email aliasing is built in rather than sold as a separate product.
  • Client apps are open source (GPL-3.0) across desktop, mobile, and browser extensions.
  • 4.9-star rating from 7 Capterra reviews.

Cons

  • Free tier's hide-my-email aliases are capped at 10.
  • Built-in 2FA authenticator and dark web monitoring require the paid Pass Plus tier.
  • Best per-dollar value comes from the pricier Proton Unlimited bundle rather than Pass alone.

Pricing: Free tier · paid from $1.99/mo$1.99/month Pass Plus vs 1Password's $3.99/month Individual (verified undefined NaN, NaN)

6.RoboForm — best 1Password alternative for individuals and families who want a genuinely unlimited free single-device password manager, with cheap multi-device and family plans compared to 1Password or Dashlane

Screenshot of RoboForm

RoboForm is the best 1Password alternative for individuals and families who want unlimited free password storage on one device before ever paying, rather than 1Password's 14-day trial that converts to billing with no free option. RoboForm's Free plan supports unlimited passwords and form-fill data on a single device at no cost, and its paid Everywhere plan runs just $2.49/month billed annually ($29.88/year), well under 1Password's $3.99/month Individual plan. RoboForm's Family plan covers up to 5 members for $3.98/month, cheaper than 1Password's $5.99/month Families plan for the same headcount, and RoboForm holds a 4.6/5 rating from 313 Capterra reviews. 1Password is still the better choice for teams that need developer-focused secrets tooling and broader support options: RoboForm has no CLI or SSH agent comparable to 1Password's for CI/CD pipelines, its reviewers report occasional unexpected logouts that interrupt access to saved logins including for banking sites, and RoboForm has no dedicated Linux desktop app, unlike 1Password which supports Linux natively. RoboForm's Free plan is also capped to a single device, so most users who want sync across devices will need to pay.

Compared to 1Password: unlimited free single-device tier vs trial-only pricing, Everywhere at $2.49/month vs $3.99/month, Family plan at $3.98/month vs $5.99/month

Wins:Free plan supports unlimited passwords on a single device at no cost, vs 1Password's 14-day-trial-only model with no free option · Everywhere plan costs $2.49/month ($29.88/year), well under 1Password's $3.99/month Individual plan · Family plan covers up to 5 members for $3.98/month, cheaper than 1Password's $5.99/month Families plan

Loses:No CLI or SSH agent comparable to 1Password's for CI/CD pipelines · Reviewers report occasional unexpected logouts that interrupt access to saved logins, including for banking sites · No dedicated Linux desktop app, unlike 1Password which supports Linux natively

Pros

  • Free plan offers genuinely unlimited passwords, not just a trial, as long as it stays on one device.
  • Everywhere and Family plans are priced below comparable tiers from 1Password and Dashlane.
  • Breach monitoring scans up to five email addresses for compromised credentials.
  • Holds a 4.6/5 rating from 313 reviews on Capterra.

Cons

  • Free plan is limited to a single device; multi-device sync requires upgrading.
  • Reviewers report occasional unexpected logouts that interrupt access to saved logins, including for banking sites.
  • No dedicated Linux desktop application, unlike some competitors that ship native Linux clients.
  • No rating found on Product Hunt or G2 at the time of research, limiting independent review coverage beyond Capterra.

Pricing: Free tier · paid from $2.49/mo$2.49/month Everywhere vs 1Password's $3.99/month Individual; RoboForm Family at $3.98/month vs 1Password Families at $5.99/month (verified undefined NaN, NaN)

7.Keeper — best 1Password alternative for businesses, MSPs, and government agencies that need password management combined with privileged access management and compliance certifications like FedRAMP High and HIPAA

Screenshot of Keeper

Keeper is the best 1Password alternative for businesses, MSPs, and government agencies that need privileged access management (PAM) and regulatory compliance on top of password storage, capabilities 1Password's CLI and Watchtower tooling don't cover. Keeper holds FedRAMP High, HIPAA, SOC 2, ISO 27001/27017/27018, and FIPS 140-3 certifications, and its PAM add-on provides just-in-time access, session recording, and KeeperAI anomaly detection that can automatically terminate risky privileged sessions — a tier of enterprise infrastructure beyond 1Password's Business plan, which tops out at SSO and Watchtower reporting for $8.99/user/month. Keeper holds a 4.7/5 rating from 507 Capterra reviews, a smaller but comparable sample to 1Password's own 4.7/5 rating from 2,130 Capterra reviews. 1Password is still the better choice for buyers who want transparent, published pricing and any kind of free option: Keeper's marketing site loads its numeric prices via JavaScript rather than static HTML, so exact current dollar figures aren't confirmable without starting a purchase flow, and Keeper offers no free tier at all, only free trials on Business, Enterprise, and PAM plans, a bigger gap than 1Password's own trial-only individual pricing.

Compared to 1Password: adds FedRAMP High and HIPAA-certified privileged access management, matches 4.7/5 Capterra rating, but hides exact pricing behind a JavaScript-rendered checkout flow

Wins:FedRAMP High, HIPAA, SOC 2, ISO 27001/27017/27018, and FIPS 140-3 certifications beyond 1Password's compliance coverage · PAM add-on provides just-in-time access, session recording, and KeeperAI anomaly detection with automatic session termination, capabilities 1Password's Business plan doesn't include · 4.7/5 rating from 507 Capterra reviews, matching 1Password's own 4.7/5 Capterra score

Loses:Exact dollar prices aren't published on the site; they load via JavaScript rather than static HTML, unlike 1Password's published per-tier pricing · No free tier at all, only free trials on Business, Enterprise, and PAM plans, a bigger gap than 1Password's own trial-only individual pricing · Rating sample of 507 Capterra reviews is much smaller than 1Password's 2,130 Capterra reviews

Pros

  • Privileged Access Management (PAM), session recording, and anomaly detection are available alongside standard password storage in one platform.
  • FedRAMP High, HIPAA, SOC 2, ISO 27001/27017/27018, and FIPS 140-3 certifications support regulated industries and government use.
  • Every Business or Enterprise seat includes a complimentary Family Plan.
  • Apps and extensions cover Windows, macOS, Linux, iOS, Android, and every major browser.

Cons

  • Public pricing page does not display dollar amounts without navigating through a purchase flow.
  • No permanently free tier for individuals; only Business, Enterprise, and PAM plans get a free trial.
  • Advanced PAM and enterprise provisioning features are geared toward IT teams, adding complexity a small business may not need.
  • Enterprise-grade feature set means many capabilities are locked behind higher tiers than competitors like Bitwarden gate.

Pricing: Custom pricing